Precious Metals for Keeps

With gas prices and virtually every other cost of living rising, responding to the declining dollar is something we all have probably thought about by now. One option available to us all is precious metals: namely gold, silver, and platinum.

The trick with getting metals into a retirement plan is in the Internal Revenue Code section that deals with collectibles. Strangely enough, it’s not in section 4975 (which deals with prohibited transactions); it’s in 408 which deals with IRAs. Even more odd is the fact that one part of this section is applicable to self directed qualified plans (like a Solo 401k) with no reference to its applicability within the code sections for qualified plans. This is why tax attorneys have work to do.

In 408(m)(2), they prohibit investment into collectibles and further define collectibles to include any metals or coins. 408(m)(3) goes on to exclude certain coins and bullion from being defined as “collectibles” for the purposes of disallowed investments. It breaks these “certain coins and bullion” down into two categories. (A) is essentially American Eagle coins minted by the United States. (B) is bullion that that meets or exceeds the fineness required by regulated futures contracts if such bullion is in possession of a custodial account at a bank or trust company.

So when it comes to Self Directed IRAs and Solo 401(k)s, it appears that American Eagle coins are allowable for both types of plans. Further, a retirement plan can (through a custodian as trustee) own certain bullion, but cannot do so with checkbook control plans (an IRA LLC or a Solo 401k that is self administered and self trusteed). This appears to offer a benefit to having your transactions handled by a custodian because doing so would allow for ownership of certain bullion (in case you’re lost, bullion is simply unminted metal of a certain purity – such as a 99.9% pure bar of gold). I would suggest that holding gold bullion at a custodian is not a good idea.

Why are you holding gold in the first place? The top reasons are usually:

  1. To store value while the dollar declines
  2. To store value while the economy and government are dealing with troubles
  3. To enjoy increased value due to an increased demand for tangible, uninflatable assets

Right now, it is undeniable that the dollar has been declining and as a general trend will continually decline as long as it is a fiat currency. Most people would further agree that the economy, banking system, and government, in general, is currently in trouble – evidenced by:

  • unusually low interest rates
  • insolvency of subprime lenders
  • mutual fund overexposure to subprime lending
  • insolvency of investment banking giant Bear Stearns
  • corporate scandals (Enron, WorldCom, etc)
  • increasing unemployment
  • the fact that goods and services are being created and rendered in China & India at an alarming rate

This situation as a whole is what makes precious metal ownership enticing. Historically, governments, economies, markets, and empires rise and fall. But since the beginning of time, gold has been valuable… always. There’s not too much “always” in our current situation anymore. There’s no more “real estate always goes up every year”. There’s no “the stock market always appreciates at 9% on average” when you look at its current volatility and look beyond a few decades of history. “Gold has always been valuable” is the only always we have left. So uncertain times cause us to revisit that fact.

We’re still talking about “it’s probably not good to own bullion at a custodian” remember? Stay with me; I promise we’re getting there. If you’ve read arguments for or against gold ownership, you’ve probably encountered the threat of confiscation. On April 5th, 1933 President Roosevelt ordered all U.S. persons to surrender all gold coins, gold bullion, and gold certificates to the Federal Reserve. Many historical accounts lead us to believe that everyone just lined up and turned in their gold.

The Collapse of the Dollar by James Turk & John Rubino suggests otherwise. Their data says that gold in circulation was declining for the few years preceding the 1933 confiscation because people anticipated the governmental confiscation and started hiding their gold because of it. The confiscation resulted in about 22% of the gold in circulation being turned in. The government claimed the rest of the gold coins were lost or destroyed – let’s be serious! Apparently, by January 1934 the missing coins were all back in circulation.

In light of the actual happenings in the gold confiscation of April 1933, there has never been an effective confiscation. If history repeats itself, would you prefer to be a person who has surrendered their wealth or who has protected it? If you’d like to protect it, you can’t do so owning bullion in a IRA custodian account. Placing bullion in the hands of a custodian (a bank or trust company) effectively surrenders it from the start in the case of future government confiscation.

If you need one more reason not to let IRC 408(m)(3)(B) bother you, it’s that ownership of minted coins is more liquid anyways. When it comes time to sell a coin, a U.S. minted American Eagle is immediately identified for its reliable purity. A gold buyer will likely not require testing of the actual coins. With bullion, that reliance on purity is not always there. The premium you pay for a minted coin is so nominal, that the extra ease in selling is surely worth it.

More precious metal food for thought is that I encourage you to also consider silver. Firstly, there has never even been an attempt by the U.S. government to confiscate silver. Secondly, the “buzz” is about gold, and much of the inflation hedging has been manifested by gold acquisition. So, the buzz has probably run the price of gold up more than the price of silver. As a third point, consider that silver has many industrial uses. It is used as a component in most electronics, and the flattening of the world (as observed by Friedman) is quite rapidly bringing cell phones and computers to billions of workers in India & China – all requiring silver in the manufacturing process.

I recently took a look at a checking account of mine that has had $15,000 in it since December of 2006. A year of that sitting there made me $6.59 in interest from Bank of America. More importantly, I did a basic calculation that told me that my $15,000 was now worth $13,122. Had I invested that $15,000 into gold during the same time period, it would be worth about $19,707 inflation adjusted. Because I was invested in U.S. currency I experienced a 12.5% loss while gold experienced a 31.4% gain. Hindsight is 20/20 and we can all become billionaires investing in the past, but in all seriousness, there was no denying that the uncontrollable floating value of the dollar was hurting me. The minute I realized what was happening to my money, I invested $6,000 into an equal split of gold, silver, and platinum. I’m receiving 0 dividends, and I don’t check the prices every day, but I have something of value. It’s probably not going to get me rich, but I’m positive these physical objects will always have value. And maybe Chindia will run up the price of my 100 ounces of silver.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jeff,

    I was looking into the gold in the IRA thing when I read your blog and was thinking the same thing, about coustodial storage, before I read it.
    Where, in the case of an IRA LLC could it be stored?

    Regards,
    Steve M

  2. Steve,

    It’s up the the LLC manager to decide how and where to store the LLC’s assets. In the case of an IRA LLC managed by you, it’s up to you.

    FYI – The IRA LLC was created in 2003 by attorney Debra Buchanan, and we’re the only company in existence that has received an authorized license and support from the the creator of the IRA LLC. Call us for more info 877-903-2220.

    Jeff

  3. Jeff, I’ve read all the info you’ve provided on buying precious metals which seemed incomplete for certainty on my part, so wanted to confirm our understanding of the situation as we move forward to buy coins for my solo 401K….

    My reading is that we can buy American Eagles, but are we strictly limited to US minted coins? I prefer Canadian Maples and Austrian Philharmonics in addition to the Eagles for various reasons, hence my question.

    It would be ideal if you could clarify in your customer documentation more succinctly what can and cannot be bought . A statement such as, “Solo 401k plan owners can ONLY buy US minted coins (if this is so) that do not have collectible value. This would include American Eagles American, Buffalo gold bullion coins, silver Walking Liberty’s and junk US silver coins, etc, etc.” This would make it very clear to your “Good Naber” investors. 😉
    Thanks!

  4. Hi, Jeff,

    Regarding this statement:

    “So when it comes to Self Directed IRAs and Solo 401(k)s, it appears that American Eagle coins are allowable for both types of plans. Further, a retirement plan can (through a custodian as trustee) own certain bullion, but cannot do so with checkbook control plans (an IRA LLC or a Solo 401k that is self administered and self trusteed).”

    Can you confirm my understanding?
    An IRA-LLC or Solo 401K (with checkbook control) can ONLY own nationally minted gold and silver coins; specifically, from the US, Canada, Australia and Austria? Bullion bars of required fineness, (in addition to nationally minted coins mentioned) can only be owned via custodians?

  5. Ok, I re-read posts and actually read the section 408 parts (that I found on inet) pertinent to this with cross references to section 5112. Based on what I understand, a retirement plan cannot own certain bullion, specifically, bars and rounds that are at least .999 fineness without using a 3rd party custodian (a bank, credit union or corp-entity governed by a state’s banking regulators) who will decide where to hold the metals. The plan can own US minted gold coins, more specifically, US minted gold coins of face value, $50, $25, $10 and $5 with corresponding fractions of fine gold content (does not mention .999 fineness, so the assumption is 22k is good enough). In addition, states that have issued coins are also eligible; however, section 408(m)(3)(A)(iv) does not mention metal type of state coins. What I do find interesting, is section 5112(a)(11) refers to 1oz gold coins of .999 fineness (24k), but section 408(m) does not include these. So it appears that US Gold Buffaloes is not IRA acceptable. Granted the section 408 that I was reading may be outdated. You indicated that IRA-LLC or Solo 401k cannot own certain gold bullion (bars & rounds) due to requirements of 3rd party custodian/trustee. But then your answer to Steve M., says the manager of the IRA-LLC decides where to store the assets (gold I presume). Am I missing something here? … To answer my own question, I am assuming that the IRA-LLC can only own US minted coins as stated earlier, and thus, I, as the manager can store them where I want, at home or buried in my backyard. If I want my IRA-LLC to own gold bullion bars or rounds, then I can’t decide where they are to be stored. The custodian will have already decided (3rd party depositiories). Am I even close?

  6. Great information. I’m leaning on going with http://www.IRAMetals.com as they have a way to make the actual metal allocated into my name. Another option is that they have private minted bullion (Scottsdale Silver) that is qualified for IRA by IRS rules and is actually cheaper than the government issue eagles for example. My account is being setup as we speak and hope that my money clears next week before gold and silver go back up!

  7. Dr D,

    Good job on taking control 🙂

    I fear that you might just be going through the motions as you will be letting a government regulated financial institution hold your physical wealth during a period of time where our government is literally going bankrupt and facing the option of suicide or a new wealth grab. Only time will tell.

    If you are truly interested in protecting your wealth against real threats, contact us and we’ll hook you up with some more genuine methods of wealth protection.

    Jeff

  8. JEFF,
    I am confused. In you article you say you cannot own gold in an IRA LLC. You also say that you CAN own gold in a self directed IRA through the custodian, but that it is not a good idea to own gold through the custodian. So… what is safest way to own gold in an IRA?

    I thought you could own gold in an IRA/LLC

    thank you
    Rich L.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

© Copyright 2003 - JeffNabers.com | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Contact

 

* DISCLAIMER

The information contained throughout this web site is not a substitute for professional advice you would receive from an accountant, attorney, investment adviser, or qualified tax preparer. The information provided does not constitute professional advice nor is it conveyed or intended to be conveyed in the course of any adviser-client discourse, but is provided for informational purposes only. If you enter your email address on our web site, you are also requesting and agreeing to subscribe to our free email newsletter, and you can unsubscribe anytime if you don't enjoy it. References to investment performance of any kind is for illustration purposes only.